Carbon Clean 200®:

Investing in a Clean Energy Future

2023 Performance Update

 
 

The Clean200® is an educational tool intended to give individuals the ability to research companies that are effectively balancing people, planet, and profit. The Clean200 list may be used by individuals free of charge. All commercial investment products derived from the Clean200 require a license. Contact [email protected] and/or Corporate Knights Inc. for further information.


Foreword

Just a few years ago, much of the business community viewed climate advocates with indifference or skepticism. Today, companies representing 40% of the global stock market have committed to science-based targets around reducing their greenhouse gas emissions in line with the Paris Agreement. In many cases, these businesses are already making billions of dollars supplying climate solutions to the market. Even corporations that are less directly implicated in the economic upside of climate action recognize the imperative for a low-carbon economy because no business can profit in an environment of climate chaos.

Yet, despite this reality being clear as day, we are plodding along on climate action. Worse, a handful of laggard companies and their pliant industry associations continue to advocate against climate action and for business as usual. The first thing we need to do is cut the poison that is at the heart of our climate breakdown.

That means finally cutting out the annual US$6 trillion in subsidies to fossil fuel companies that accounts for two-thirds of global greenhouse gas emissions.

It also means cutting off financing for new fossil fuel projects, which HSBC (one of the largest banks in the world) and Lloyds (the largest domestic bank in the U.K.) have done for new oil and gas fields – with some caveats.

And it means stopping all finance for activities that are killing our forests. Deforestation accounts for 11% of global greenhouse gas emissions, more than comes out of the tailpipes of all 1.4 billion cars on the world’s roads. If we went a step further than putting a stop to ripping out our forests and mangroves and started to restore them, we could get almost 40% of the way to our Paris Agreement goals by 2030.

But as former Bank of England (and Canada) governor Mark Carney has made clear, “the biggest threat to achieving 1.5 degrees is the speed at which we invest, not divest. We need at least $4 in clean energy investment for every $1 maintaining fossil fuels until we can phase them out by the end of this decade.”

The good news is that over the past decade, the flow of money into clean energy and efficiency infrastructure has tripled to about US$1 trillion annually. According to research from Bloomberg, global investments in clean energy transition reached US$1.1 trillion in 2022. This amount was roughly equal to the amount invested in fossil fuel production in the same year.

The Clean200 lists the 200 major corporate players from 35 countries around the world that are at the forefront of this transition. These are the companies that are leading the way by putting sustainability at the heart of their products, services, business models and investments, helping to move the world onto a more sustainable trajectory.

This year’s Clean200 companies rose to the top of a pool of 6,720 global firms based on rigorous assessment of the amount of revenue each company earns from products and services aligned with the Corporate Knights Sustainable Economy Taxonomy, while also ensuring that their businesses are not fundamentally offside important criteria for socially responsible investors, including being a company flagged by As You Sow’s Invest Your Values platform, which identifies fossil fuels, weapons, private prisons, thermal coal or having a record of systemically obstructing climate policy.

Key Findings:

Geographically, the Americas and Europe account for 38.5% and 31.5% respectively of this year’s Clean200, while the remaining 60 companies are headquartered in the Asia Pacific region. The United States dominated the 2023 list, with 42 companies on the Clean200, while China had the second-largest share with 21, followed by Japan, which is headquarters to 16 Clean200 companies.

On average, 58.3% of revenues earned by Clean200 companies are classified as sustainable, representing close to $2.4 trillion in revenue, roughly unchanged from last year and significantly above the 5% average sustainable revenue for their MSCI ACWI peers.

Of note, it was found that on average, 44.4% of the capital expenditure, acquisitions, and research and development expenses among the Clean200 companies were defined as sustainable by the Corporate Knights Sustainable Economy Taxonomy, compared to only 7% among MSCI ACWI constituents.

Of the 2023 Clean200 companies, the Information Technology sector accounted for nearly a quarter of the total sustainable revenue at $586 billion, followed by the Communications Services sector ($542 billion) and the Industrials sector ($400 billion). On Sustainable Investments, the Utilities and Industrials sector led with $50 billion each, followed by the Communications Services sector at $24 billion in Sustainable Investments.

U.S. companies had, on average, the highest Sustainable Revenue at $23 billion. This is followed by Germany with $18 billion and South Korea at $17 billion.

But none of this would have legs if the Clean200 weren’t also faring well financially. On this score, as of January 31, 2023, the Clean200 outperformed its MSCI ACWI peers by 3.36% since the Clean200 was launched in July of 2016. Clean200 companies generated a total return of 91.21%, beating the MSCI ACWI broad market index (87.84%) and MSCI ACWI/Energy Index of fossil fuel companies (61.31%) on Total Return Gross — USD Basis from the Clean200 inception of July 1, 2016, to January 31, 2023.

To put that in context: US$10,000 invested in the Clean200 on July 1, 2016, would have grown to $19,121 by January 31, 2023, versus $18,784 for the MSCI ACWI broad market benchmark and $16,131 for the MSCI ACWI/Energy benchmark for fossil fuel companies.

Looking Ahead:

This decade we need to move faster, quadrupling current levels of investment to the US$4 trillion annually (4% of global GDP) that is required, according to the International Energy Agency.

Finance ministers hold the keys to unlocking climate action. Fortunately, a new group, called the Coalition of Finance Ministers for Climate Action, from more than 80 countries, is looking to shift the view of climate action from a cost to a unique growth and investment opportunity. These finance ministers recognize that the current energy crisis and growing incidence of climate hazards are an opportunity for more, not less, action. And a rapid switch to renewable energy presents an opportunity for countries to deliver clean, cheap, secure energy and new employment at the same time.

Finance ministers globally manage huge annual budgets that collectively add up to around 30% of gross domestic product. Mobilizing 4% of global GDP for climate action is not going to happen without backing from heads of state, most critically those from the G20 countries. It is a tall task but one with precedent. It wasn’t that long ago that governments mobilized trillions of dollars to keep businesses and workers afloat during the early days of the COVID-19 pandemic.

Corporate Knights and As You Sow are pleased to present the latest edition of the Clean200 to help investors identify the companies that are leading the charge on providing climate solutions while outperforming both the broad-based benchmark and its high-carbon global counterparts.

 

Clean200 vs MSCI ACWI vs MSCI ACWI/Energy
(July 1, 2016–Jan. 31, 2023, Total Return USD Gross)

Source: S&P Capital IQ

 
 
 

Clean200 Companies by Sector

GICS Sector # of Clean200 Companies
Industrials 49
Information Technology 34
Materials 30
Utilities 26
Consumer Discretionary 17
Communication Services 16
Health Care 10
Financials 9
Consumer Staples 6
Real Estate 3
 
 

Clean200 Companies by Country

 
Country # of Clean200 Companies
United States 42
China 21
Japan 16
Canada 12
France 11
Brazil 10
Germany 10
Cayman Islands 8
Netherlands 6
United Kingdom 6
Spain 5
Taiwan 5
Switzerland 4
Finland 4
Ireland 4
Singapore 3
Denmark 3
Bermuda 3
South Korea 3
Belgium 2
Australia 2
Italy 2
Hong Kong 2
Thailand 2
Philippines 2
Sweden 2
India 2
Mexico 1
Turkey 1
Portugal 1
Norway 1
Colombia 1
New Zealand 1
Austria 1
Poland 1
 
 

The Clean200® Methodology

The Clean200 are the largest 200 public companies ranked by clean revenue. The ranking was first calculated on July 1, 2016, and publicly released on August 15, 2016, by Corporate Knights and As You Sow. The current list has been updated with data through January 31, 2023.

The Clean200 companies are ranked by their clean revenues in U.S. dollars. The data set is developed through assessment of a company’s revenue that aligns with the definitions laid out in the Corporate Knights Sustainable Economy Taxonomy, primarily sourced from Corporate Knights research. To be eligible, a company must earn more than 10% of total revenues from clean sources.

The Clean200 uses negative screens. It excludes all oil and gas companies, all utilities that generate less than 50% of their power from green sources, the top 100 coal companies measured by reserves, the top 100 oil and gas companies as measured by reserves, as well as all fossil fuel companies, majority fossil-fired utilities, pipeline and oil-field-services companies, and other fossil-fuel-related companies screened on As You Sow’s Fossil Free Funds. In addition, the Clean200 excludes weapons companies, including major military arms manufacturers found on the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute (SIPRI) Top 100 arms-producing and military services list, as well as cluster munitions, nuclear weapons and civilian firearm manufacturers screened on As You Sow’s Weapon Free Funds. The Clean200 also excludes palm oil, paper/pulp, rubber, timber, cattle and soy producers that are screened on As You Sow’s Deforestation Free Funds; companies that use child or forced labour, are involved in the manufacture of harmful pesticides, and that engage in negative climate lobbying are not included. The full list of exclusionary screens is provided below. 

Clean200 Negative Screens Criteria # Excluded
Blocking climate policy Categorized by the InfluenceMap lobbying red flag metric, which highlights companies that are engaged in corporate lobbying on climate change. (Source: CK) 2
Cement carbon laggards Companies in the cement industry that were divested from by Norges Bank Investment Management (NBIM). (Source: CK) 0
Deforestation-risk agribusiness producer/trader Company engages in deforestation in South America and Southeast Asia as deemed by Chain Reaction research, Deforestation Free Funds, or was divested from by NBIM. (Source: CK, AYS) 5
Coal Industry Company has coal industry classification, or is found on the Global Coal Exit list from Urgewald. (Source: CK + AYS) 29
Oil & gas industry Company has industry classification of oil/gas, or is found on the Global Oil/Gas Exit list from Urgewald. (Source: CK, AYS) 10
Fossil-fired utilities Company has industry classification of utilities, has fossil fuel power generation or gas distribution, and has less than 50% clean revenue, as calculated by Corporate Knights. (Source: CK, AYS) 11
Fossil fuel financers Company is found on the Banking on Climate Chaos list of the 60 largest commercial and investment banks that are lending to and underwriting debt/equity issuances of fossil fuel companies, or from Corporate Knights research. (Source: AYS) 0
Fossil fuel insurers Company is found on the Insure Our Future list of 30 leading primary insurers and reinsurers that are insuring and investing in coal, oil, gas. (Source: AYS) 0
Conventional weapons Company is found on the list of the top 100 military contractors, or company earns more than half of its revenue from conventional weapons, as tracked by the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute (SIPRI). (Source: CK) 1
Prisons Company is recommended for divestment by the Investigate project of the American Friends Service Committee. (Source: CK, AYS) 0
Top 200 carbon reserve owners Company ranks in The Carbon Underground 200™, compiled and maintained by FFI Solutions (formerly Fossil Free Indexes℠), which identifies the top 100 coal and the top 100 oil/gas publicly traded reserve holders globally. (Source: AYS) 0
Controversial weapons Company sells controversial weapons and is deemed ineligible for investment by NBIM and NZ SuperFund. (Source: CK) 2
Illegal activity Company’s ratio of fines, penalties or settlements/revenue for the most recent ranked year exceeds 1.0%. (Source: CK) 2
Severe environmental damage Identifies companies that have caused several environmental damage and have been excluded by NBIM. (Source: CK) 1
Harmful pesticides The top five pesticide manufacturers selling chemicals that pose serious hazards to human health and the environment. (Source: Unearthed) 1

* From the companies eligible for the 2023 Clean200

 

The Clean200® List

Rank Name Country GICS Sector
1 Apple Inc United States Information Technology
2 Alphabet Inc United States Communication Services
3 Deutsche Telekom AG Germany Communication Services
4 Verizon Communications Inc United States Communication Services
5 Tesla Inc United States Consumer Discretionary
6 Agricultural Bank of China Ltd China Financials
7 TSMC Taiwan Information Technology
8 Iberdrola SA Spain Utilities
9 HP Inc United States Information Technology
10 Contemporary Amperex Technology Co Ltd China Industrials
11 Schneider Electric SE France Industrials
12 Cisco Systems Inc United States Information Technology
13 Intel Corp United States Information Technology
14 Nucor Corp United States Materials
15 Siemens AG Germany Industrials
16 CRRC Corp Ltd China Industrials
17 SoftBank Corp Japan Communication Services
18 Unilever PLC United Kingdom Consumer Staples
19 KDDI Corp Japan Communication Services
20 Vestas Wind Systems A/S Denmark Industrials
21 LG Chem Ltd Republic of Korea Materials
22 Adidas AG Germany Consumer Discretionary
23 Tianneng Power International Ltd Cayman Islands Consumer Discretionary
24 LONGi Green Energy Technology Co Ltd China Information Technology
25 Steel Dynamics Inc United States Materials
26 Bank of China Ltd China Financials
27 BT Group PLC United Kingdom Communication Services
28 ABB Ltd Switzerland Industrials
29 SK Telecom Co Ltd Republic of Korea Communication Services
30 Siemens Gamesa Renewable Energy SA Spain Industrials
31 Advanced Info Service PCL Thailand Communication Services
32 Indorama Ventures PCL Thailand Materials
33 BNP Paribas SA France Financials
34 Pfizer Inc United States Health Care
35 Hewlett Packard Enterprise Co United States Information Technology
36 EDP Energias de Portugal SA Portugal Utilities
37 CEMIG Brazil Utilities
38 Samsung SDI Co Ltd Republic of Korea Information Technology
39 Centrais Elétricas Brasileiras SA Brazil Utilities
40 Johnson Controls International PLC Ireland Industrials
41 Banco do Brasil SA Brazil Financials
42 Enerjisa Enerji AS Turkey Utilities
43 Xinjiang Goldwind Science & Technology Co Ltd China Industrials
44 BYD Co Ltd China Consumer Discretionary
45 Gilead Sciences Inc United States td> Health Care
46 Bristol-Myers Squibb Co United States Health Care
47 China Yangtze Power Co Ltd China Utilities
48 Alstom SA France Industrials
49 Sanofi SA France Health Care
50 Carrier Global Corp United States Industrials
51 Shin-Etsu Chemical Co Ltd Japan Materials
52 Nine Dragons Paper (Holdings) Ltd Bermuda Materials
53 Kone Oyj Finland Industrials
54 DS Smith PLC United Kingdom Materials
55 Rexel SA France Industrials
56 Outokumpu Oyj Finland Materials
57 Kering SA France Consumer Discretionary
58 SAP SE Germany Information Technology
59 Union Pacific Corp United States Industrials
60 JinkoSolar Holding Co Ltd Cayman Islands Information Technology
61 VMware Inc United States Information Technology
62 Umicore SA Belgium Materials
63 Energisa SA Brazil Utilities
64 Merck KGaA Germany Health Care
65 BCE Inc Canada Communication Services
66 Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson Sweden Information Technology
67 Ecolab Inc United States Materials
68 Telus Corp Canada Communication Services
69 Air Liquide SA France Materials
70 Capital One Financial Corp United States Financials
71 NIO Inc Cayman Islands Consumer Discretionary
72 Sumitomo Electric Industries Ltd Japan Consumer Discretionary
73 Applied Materials Inc United States Information Technology
74 Prysmian SpA Italy Industrials
75 Nordex SE Germany Industrials
76 Kingspan Group PLC Ireland Industrials
77 Panasonic Corp Japan Consumer Discretionary
78 Lenovo Group Ltd Hong Kong Information Technology
79 Swisscom AG Switzerland Communication Services
80 Ørsted A/S Denmark Utilities
81 Bank of Communications Co Ltd China Financials
82 Nokia Oyj Finland Information Technology
83 Industria de Diseño Textil SA Spain Consumer Discretionary
84 Industrial Bank Co Ltd China Financials
85 International Business Machines Corp United States Information Technology
86 Smurfit Kappa Group PLC Ireland Materials
87 Toray Industries Inc Japan Materials
88 Commercial Metals Co United States Materials
89 Essity AB (publ) Sweden Consumer Staples
90 Li Auto Inc Cayman Islands Consumer Discretionary
91 Yadea Group Holdings Ltd Cayman Islands Consumer Discretionary
92 Nexans SA France Industrials
93 Asustek Computer Inc Taiwan Information Technology
94 Sims Ltd Australia Materials
95 China Everbright Environment Group Ltd Hong Kong Industrials
96 Waste Connections US Inc Canada Industrials
97 Singapore Telecommunications Ltd Singapore Communication Services
98 Signify NV Netherlands Industrials
99 Henkel AG & Co KGaA Germany Consumer Staples
100 Sungrow Power Supply Co Ltd China Industrials
101 Akzo Nobel NV Netherlands Materials
102 Evonik Industries AG Germany Materials
103 Brambles Ltd Australia Industrials
104 Astellas Pharma Inc Japan Health Care
105 Chunghwa Telecom Co Ltd Taiwan Communication Services
106 Giant Manufacturing Co Ltd Taiwan Consumer Discretionary
107 CSX Corp United States Industrials
108 Xerox Holdings Corp United States Information Technology
109 Rogers Communications Inc Canada Communication Services
110 Companhia Paranaense de Energia Brazil Utilities
111 Trane Technologies PLC Ireland Industrials
112 Norfolk Southern Corp United States Industrials
113 Koninklijke KPN NV Netherlands Communication Services
114 East Japan Railway Co Japan Industrials
115 Huaneng Lancang River Hydropower Inc China Utilities
116 Konica Minolta Inc Japan Information Technology
117 Dassault Systèmes SE France Information Technology
118 GCL-Poly Energy Holdings Ltd Cayman Islands Information Technology
119 Canadian National Railway Co Canada Industrials
120 Engie Brasil Energia SA Brazil Utilities
121 Danaher Corp United States Health Care
122 Stanley Black & Decker Inc United States Industrials
123 GEM Co Ltd China Materials
124 China Railway Signal & Communication Corp Ltd China Information Technology
125 FirstGroup PLC United Kingdom Industrials
126 Acciona SA Spain Utiliies
127 Rengo Co Ltd Japan Materials
128 Shimano Inc Japan Consumer Discretionary
129 Risen Energy Co Ltd China Information Technology
130 Veolia Environnement SA France Utilities
131 GS Yuasa Corp Japan Industrials
132 Canadian Solar Inc Canada Information Technology
133 WSP Global Inc Canada Industrials
134 West Fraser Timber Co Ltd Canada Materials
135 Light Serviços de Eletricidade SA Brazil Utilities
136 Lopez Holdings Corp Philippines Utilities
137 Autodesk Inc United States Information Technology
138 Brookfield Renewable Partners LP Bermuda Utilities
139 Koninklijke Philips NV Netherlands Health Care
140 Johnson Matthey PLC United Kingdom Materials
141 Proximus NV Belgium Communication Services
142 Kimberly-Clark Corp United States Consumer Staples
143 Rockwool A/S Denmark Industrials
144 Clean Harbors Inc United States Industrials
145 Ricoh Co Ltd Japan Information Technology
146 China Three Gorges Renewables Group Co Ltd China Utilities
147 Intesa Sanpaolo SpA Italy Financials
148 Zhuzhou CRRC Times Electric Co Ltd China Industrials
149 Beijing Enterprises Water Group Ltd Bermuda Utilities
150 KGHM Polska Miedz SA Poland Materials
151 Swatch Group AG Switzerland Consumer Discretionary
152 EnerSys United States Industrials
153 Celestica Inc Canada Information Technology
154 Stadler Rail AG Switzerland Industrials
155 Equinix Inc United States Real Estate
156 McCormick & Company Inc United States Consumer Staples
157 Acuity Brands Inc United States Industrials
158 Sherwin-Williams Co United States Materials
159 MLS Co Ltd China Information Technology
160 Companhia de Saneamento Básico do Estado de Sao Paulo SABESP Brazil Utilities
161 Camel Group Co Ltd China Industrials
162 Suzlon Energy Ltd India Industrials
163 First Solar Inc United States Information Technology
164 Cascades Inc Canada Materials
165 Puma SE Germany Consumer Discretionary
166 Dupont De Nemours Inc United States Materials
167 Cheng Loong Corp Taiwan Materials
168 Wartsila Oyj Abp Finland Industrials
169 Canadian Pacific Railway Ltd Canada Industrials
170 Packaging Corp of America United States Materials
171 China Datang Corp Renewable Power Co Ltd China Utilities
172 West Japan Railway Co Japan Industrials
173 Valeo SA France Consumer Discretionary
174 Schnitzer Steel Industries Inc United States Materials
175 Xinyi Solar Holdings Ltd Cayman Islands Information Technology
176 Atea ASA Norway Information Technology
177 Renewi PLC United Kingdom Industrials
178 Greif Inc United States Materials
179 Companhia de Eletricidade do Estado da Bahia Coelba Brazil Utilities
180 Geely Automobile Holdings Ltd Cayman Islands Consumer Discretionary
181 Workday Inc United States Information Technology
182 STMicroelectronics NV Netherlands Information Technology
183 Eisai Co Ltd Japan Health Care
184 CapitaLand Investment Ltd Singapore Real Estate
185 Meridian Energy Ltd New Zealand Utilities
186 ASM International NV Netherlands Information Technology
187 GMexico Transportes SAB de CV Mexico Industrials
188 Central Japan Railway Co Japan Industrials
189 Lanxess AG Germany Materials
190 Brookfield Renewable Corp Canada Utilities
191 Celsia SA ESP Colombia Utilities
192 Sterling & Wilson Solar Ltd India Industrials
193 City Developments Ltd Singapore Real Estate
194 Gotion High-tech Co Ltd China Industrials
195 Verbund AG Austria Utilities
196 Natura & Co Holding SA Brazil Consumer Staples
197 Metropolitan Bank and Trust Co Philippines Financials
198 Viatris Inc United States Health Care
199 AECOM United States Industrials
200 EDP Renovaveis SA Spain Utilities

Creative Commons License