Home | About Us | Publications & Media | Join eNews | Search   
As You Sow Planting Seeds For Social Change
 

Electronics Recycling

Best Buy Offers E-Waste Recycling Nationwide

After shareholder pressure from AYS, Best Buy, the largest U.S. electronics retailer, began to offer e-waste recycling, mostly for free, at all of its 1,006 U.S. stores February 15.

The company began to move toward that goal last year after AYS filed a shareholder proposal that was withdrawn after Best Buy agreed to a pilot take back project at 100 stores in three regions last June.  The pilot was a great success, according to the company and led to the planned roll out of a nationwide system.

Most electronics will be accepted for free but TVs and CRT monitors will be charged a $10 fee. However, that fee will be partly offset by a $10 gift certificate given to customers. Click here for more details.

“This will keep millions of old TVs and other old electronics out of landfills and provide a model for other electronics retailers to follow,” said Conrad MacKerron, CSR program director, who leads the dialogue with Best Buy.  But there are still important issues to address. The company is bearing the short-term cost but electronics manufacturers need to take eventual responsibility for e-waste. 

On June 2, 2008 Best Buy began to test free electronics take back at more than 100 stores, following As You Sow’s engagement with the company. The lack of a convenient network of sites for consumers to return used electronic equipment may play a significant role in low recycling rates. This action by Best Buy action can help provide a network of locations to recycle discarded televisions before the upcoming “Digital Deadline” switch to digital TV reception which has now been extended to June 2009.  AYS will continue to engage the company to assure its vendors bar hazardous components from export to developing countries. Activist groups have uncovered unsafe e-waste dumping and processing sites in China and Nigeria. AYS continues to dialogue with Wal-Mart to enact similar take back policies.

Related resources:

Apple to Triple E-Waste Take-back

May 2007, Apple Inc. became the third major U.S. computer brand to set public take back goals for recycling old computers at the request of shareholders led by As You Sow. Apple's announcement, comes a week before a shareholder resolution asking the company to report on its recycling efforts, filed by As You Sow on behalf of the Educational Foundation of America, comes to a vote.

As You Sow met with Jobs and CFO Peter Oppenheimer in February 2007 to discuss the need for aggressive take back recovery goals and other improvements in computer recycling and chemical policies. We also presented a letter from 15 socially concerned financial insitutions reinforcing our requests. Read more in the Wall Street Journal.

The text of Jobs’ commitment can be found here

See Conrad MacKerron on your Green Report

Electronic waste is the fastest growing component of our waste stream, growing nearly three times faster than municipal waste. Although computers and televisions contain significant levels of toxic compounds including lead, mercury, cadmium, and hexavalent chromium, most computers are currently not recycled or even disposed of properly. This is creating a growing hazard as toxic elements can seep into groundwater or expose workers. Studies have stated that between 315 to 600 million desk tops and laptops will be obsolete in the United States in the next few years. One report estimates that a pile of these obsolete computers would reach a mile high and cover six acres. That's the same as a 22-story pile of e-waste covering the entire 472 square miles of the City of Los Angeles.

As You Sow is leading or participating in concurrent dialogues with the four major U.S. computer manufacturers-Apple, Dell, Hewlett-Packard, and IBM. We are urging these industry leaders to take responsibility for most of the cost of product recycling; to reach an industry-wide agreement on infrastructure for efficient product take back; and develop better systems for safe, transparent breakdown and recycling of products.

As You Sow is proud to report significant success in moving computer makers toward more responsible practices:

Apple Computer in 2006 responded to As You Sow by implementing a free computer recycling program for customers who buy new computers. In turn Dell announced it would accept any Dell computer even without the purchase of a new one.

In response to our requests for measurable goals, Dell set and surpassed its initial take-back goal of recycling 50% more equipment in fiscal year 2005 than it did in fiscal 2004. Also, HP committed to an initial recycling goal.

Dell has developed a system of electronics recovery for others to emulate by providing financial incentives to employees to encourage take back, and by viewing its take back operations as a profit center rather than a cost.

Using publicly released data and a rate of return metric, As You Sow developed a preliminary ranking of computer take-back leaders and laggards. We also note significant hurdles to be overcome to achieve better reporting.

We are working with human rights activists to press these same companies to monitor how workers assembling electronics are treated in contract supplier factories. In response, leading companies have developed a common code of vendor conduct and are working on implementation of it.

A future goal of our work is to focus on safe disposal of old computer systems. While it is laudable to keep old units out of landfills, we want to ensure that smelting or incineration of computer components does not create new environmental hazards.

 

 

Home | Contact us | Publications & Media | Join eNews | Search
©2010 As You Sow Foundation